Friday, May 13, 2005

Victor Davis Hanson & WWII Revisionist History

Hanson has some thoughts on revisionism which makes the US the bad guy.
Of course, we bombed German civilian centers. But in a total war when 10,000 a day were being gassed in the death camps, and Nazi armies in the Balkans, Russia, and Western Europe were routinely murdering thousands a week and engaged in breakneck efforts to create ballistic missiles, sophisticated jets, and worse weapons, there were very few options in stopping such a monstrous regime....

When the lumbering and often unescorted bombers started out against Europe and Japan, the Axis infrastructure of death — rails, highways, communications, warehouses, and decentralized production — was intact. When the bombers finished their horrific work, the economies of both Axis powers were near ruin. Armies that were systematically murdering millions of innocents in forgotten places like Yugoslavia, Poland, the Philippines, Korea, and China were running out of fuel, ammunition, and food.

Revisionism holds a strange attraction for the winners of World War II. American textbooks discuss World War II as if...the war was essentially the Japanese internment and Hiroshima...

If we were to listen to the Chinese, World War II was about the gallant work of Mao’s partisans, who in fact used the war to gain power, and then went on to kill 50 million of their own citizens...

But again, most Americans never learned the standard narrative of War II — only what was wrong about it. Whereas it is salutary that an American 17-year-old knows something of the Japanese relocation ordered by liberals such as Earl Warren and FDR, or of the creation and the dropping of the atomic bomb by successive Democratic administrations, they might wish to examine what went on in Nanking, Baatan, Wake Island, Guadalcanal, Manila, or Manchuria — atrocities that their sensitive teachers are probably clueless about as well...
It occurred to me some time back that the Japanese were terrificly lucky that the Japanese gang-rapes of 100,000 Korean "Comfort Women" ie sex slaves were not widely known in the US by the summer of 1945. Given the then existing American hatred of the Japanese for their known atrocities, widespread revulsion at the rape camps might well have led to public insistance to simply nuke Japan from north to south, east to west, until there were no Japanese to surrender.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tom...

This is my understanding of Allied terrorism (deliberate bombing of civilians) in WW II:

At first, the Allies bombed military targets in the daytime, since everything was targeted optically. But if the bombers could see their targets, the Germans could see the bombers.

Allied losses were unacceptable, so they switched to bombing at night. Now the problem was that they couldn't hit their targets.

So they switched from explosives to incendiaries, hoping to start fires in hospitals and orphanages that would spread to the factories. This was not very effective, except when everything worked just right, like Dresden.

So, as I see it, this was not "bombing civilians was justified because it was the only way to stop the Nazis." It's more like "they had all these bombs and they had to bomb something but the military targets were too hard to hit so they bombed civilians."

Friday, May 13, 2005 at 5:46:00 PM HST  
Blogger TTB said...

In a message dated 5/13/2005 10:46:30 PM Central Standard Time, anonymous-comment@blogger.com writes:
>>So, as I see it, this was not "bombing civilians was justified because it was the only way to stop the Nazis." It's more like "they had all these bombs and they had to bomb something but the military targets were too hard to hit so they bombed civilians."<<

I think that works. They did have to bomb something, and the military targets were hard to hit. Voila. Dresden. And Berlin. And that helped stop the Nazis. And, of course, Nagasaki and Hiroshima helped beat the Japanese fascists.

Friday, May 13, 2005 at 5:55:00 PM HST  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home